The debate around voluntary labelling on alcohol has been running in the UK for years, and in 2025, it has reached a decisive turning point. The government has announced its intention to move from the current voluntary system to mandatory requirements. The question that matters is not whether the industry will comply. It is whether any form of labelling, voluntary or mandatory, actually changes the way people drink.
At Branding Innovations, we develop food and drink brands. We understand packaging, consumer communication, and what actually drives purchasing decisions. This article examines the voluntary labelling debate honestly with the evidence, the commercial context, and a clear perspective on what genuinely works.
Where the UK Currently Stands on Alcohol Labelling
In stark contrast to the mandatory labelling requirements for all other food and drink products, which are independently regulated, alcoholic drinks labelling currently relies on voluntary adherence to UK Government and industry guidance.
The Portman Group — the UK alcohol industry’s self-regulatory body, founded in 1989 — oversees the voluntary system. Its best-practice guidance recommends that alcohol labels carry:
- Pregnancy warnings (logo or message)
- Unit content information
- UK Chief Medical Officers’ guideline (no more than 14 units per week)
- Drinkaware or other responsibility messaging
- Calorie information
- Drink-driving warnings
- Age restriction messages
A recent Portman Group market review of approximately 500 alcohol products found near-universal compliance with its minimum recommendations. Over 99% of labels carry a pregnancy warning logo or message. 96% carry alcohol unit content information. 86% carry the UK Chief Medical Officers guideline not to regularly drink more than 14 units per week. 92% carry a reference to Drinkaware or other responsibility messaging.
But compliance with minimum recommendations is not the same as comprehensive consumer information. 62% of products carried calorie information, 48% included a warning against drink driving, and 41% displayed an age-restriction warning. When nearly four in ten products carry no drink-driving warning and fewer than half carry calorie information, the voluntary system has clear gaps.
The Government’s Move Toward Mandatory Requirements
Announced as part of the “Fit for the Future” 10 Year Health Plan for England in July 2025, the UK Government stated it would strengthen and expand on existing voluntary guidelines for alcohol labelling by introducing a mandatory requirement for alcoholic drinks to display consistent nutritional information and health warning messages.
A mandatory requirement will bring alcohol labelling in line with existing health and nutritional labelling requirements for tobacco, food and alcohol-free drinks — all of which currently have more detailed nutritional and health information on their labels than alcoholic drinks.
Calorie and nutrition information will become mandatory on alcohol labels, bringing alcoholic drinks in line with the requirements already placed on food and non-alcoholic drinks. Health warning messages will be required, though the exact wording and format are yet to be specified through consultation.
The Scottish Government is also involved. The Scottish Government is currently working alongside other UK nations to support the UK Government’s commitment to expand on the existing voluntary guidelines for alcohol labelling by introducing a mandatory requirement for alcoholic drinks to display consistent nutritional information.
The direction of travel is clear. The question the industry — and public health advocates — are asking is whether mandatory labels will achieve what voluntary ones have not.
The Consumer Knowledge Gap That Labels Must Address
The data on what UK consumers actually know about the alcohol they drink is striking.
75% of people did not know or inaccurately estimated the calorie content of a pint of 5% lager. 78% did not know or inaccurately estimated the calorie content of a 175ml glass of 12% wine. 89% did not know or inaccurately estimated the calorie content of a 25ml measure of 40% ABV spirits.
These are not marginal knowledge gaps. They represent fundamental consumer ignorance about the calorie content of one of the most widely consumed product categories in the UK. Alcohol represents significant calorie intake for many regular drinkers — yet it sits outside the mandatory nutritional labelling requirements that apply to every other food and drink product on the same supermarket shelf.
Displaying the nutritional content of a beverage along with health warnings allows consumers to make an informed decision about what they are drinking. This is especially important if consumers are unaware of the health risks associated with alcohol.
The UK spends a greater proportion of its healthcare budget on diseases caused by excess alcohol consumption than the OECD average. The public health case for better consumer information is not theoretical — it is costing the NHS billions every year.
Does Labelling Actually Change Behaviour?
This is the central question — and the evidence is more nuanced than either side of the debate typically acknowledges.
The Portman Group’s position is that voluntary compliance is working. The Portman Group says that its survey shows that voluntary compliance is working when it comes to giving consumers more information about their products: “The results of our market review demonstrate already near levels of voluntary compliance regarding our best practice guidelines, which ensures consumers have access to a range of health information without the need for government mandate and at no cost to the taxpayer.”
The Alcohol Health Alliance’s position is more critical. Current product labels are clearly failing consumers, with the alcohol industry continuing to keep people in the dark about the contents and health risks of its products.
Both positions contain truth — and they are not as contradictory as they appear. Voluntary compliance has improved significantly. The minimum information fields are now almost universally present. But minimum information fields are not the same as effective health communication.
The evidence on whether labelling changes consumption is more encouraging than the industry sometimes acknowledges. Studies suggest that including health warnings on alcohol labels would raise awareness of health risks and may encourage reduced consumption. Specific warnings, such as for cancer, were found to be particularly effective. A Canadian intervention found that prominent labels with drinking guidelines, a cancer warning, and unit information led to increased awareness and knowledge of drinking guidelines and alcohol’s role in causing cancer, as well as a 6.3% reduction in consumption.
A 6.3% reduction in consumption from a label change is a significant public health outcome. The evidence from international implementations — particularly Ireland, which passed mandatory alcohol labelling legislation in 2023 — will provide further data for the UK consultation process.
The Industry’s Argument: Voluntary Works, Mandatory Is Unnecessary
The drinks industry has consistently argued that the voluntary system works — and that mandatory requirements create unnecessary cost and regulatory burden without material benefit.
Miles Beale, the chief executive of the Wine and Spirit Trade Association (WSTA), said: “The drinks industry already supports the UK’s highly successful voluntary labelling scheme and is keen to work closely with Government on this agenda. The industry has a strong record in providing important information for consumers to make healthy choices. Many wine and spirit products already carry calorie information on labels, and the majority show units of alcohol, as well as the CMO guidelines.”
For producers, especially smaller companies or importers working across several markets, any move toward mandatory wording or format rules could bring added packaging costs and operational changes.
These are legitimate concerns — particularly for small and independent producers for whom packaging redesign represents a high proportional cost. The transition to mandatory labelling will require artwork changes, new printing plates, and potentially new label formats. For a small craft brewer or independent wine producer, this is a material cost.
The counterargument is equally clear. If the voluntary system genuinely worked — if it produced consistent, comprehensive consumer information across all products — mandatory requirements would be unnecessary. The gaps in calorie information, drink-driving warnings, and age-restriction messages documented in the Portman Group’s own survey demonstrate that voluntary compliance, however improved, has not closed the information gap the public health case requires.
The Comparison That Changes the Conversation
The comparison between alcohol labelling and food labelling requirements is one that the voluntary labelling debate cannot ignore.
As of 2021, only 47% of drinks within the Portman Group voluntarily offer calorie information on the labelling. This requirement contrasts sharply with UK food regulations. UK law requires manufacturers of all pre-packed foods to display a nutritional declaration. Manufacturers must state the energy content in both kJ and kcal and disclose the amounts of fat, saturates, carbohydrates, sugars, protein, and salt.
A chocolate bar manufacturer must declare calorie content, while a wine producer does not have to provide the same information, despite wine often containing more calories per unit volume. This regulatory inconsistency strengthens the case for mandatory alcohol labelling and more transparent consumer information standards.
Consumers who are actively managing their calorie intake, their sugar consumption, or their overall health are making decisions across an uneven information landscape. Mandatory labelling corrects that asymmetry.
What Mandatory Labelling Should Include
For mandatory alcohol labelling to deliver genuine public health benefit — rather than simply adding information that consumers do not engage with — the evidence suggests several specific requirements:
Calorie information — declared per serving and per container, in a consistent format comparable to food product labels. This is the single information gap that has the most direct relevance to the largest number of consumers managing their health.
Unit content per container — currently present on 96% of products voluntarily. Making this mandatory would close the remaining 4% gap and establish a consistent format across all products.
Cancer warnings — the evidence from Canada specifically suggests that warnings linking alcohol to cancer risk generate measurably higher awareness than generic health warnings. The Irish mandatory labelling legislation, which includes cancer warnings, will provide further evidence for the UK consultation.
CMO guidelines — the 14 units per week guidance should appear on every alcoholic product, in a consistent and prominent format, not buried in a corner of the back label.
Ingredient list — alcohol remains exempt from the ingredient declaration requirements that apply to every other food product. This exemption is increasingly difficult to defend when consumer demand for ingredient transparency is at its highest level in the UK food market.
What This Means for Drinks Brands
For drinks brands currently operating in the UK market, the shift from voluntary to mandatory labelling has specific commercial implications.
Artwork and packaging costs — mandatory requirements will require label artwork updates across all products. The transition timeline, which will be determined through the government’s consultation process, will shape how disruptive this cost is. Brands that begin the artwork update process proactively — building the required information into the next natural packaging revision cycle — will manage the transition more efficiently.
Competitive positioning — for health-positioned, alcohol-free, and low-alcohol brands, mandatory calorie and health information on alcoholic competitors actually strengthens their commercial positioning. A consumer who can compare a functional soft drink’s 15 calories with an equivalent alcoholic drink’s 200+ calories has a clearer reason to choose the healthier option.
Brand trust — the brands that lead on transparency rather than wait to be required to comply are the ones that build consumer trust most effectively. In 2025, voluntary adoption of comprehensive labelling is a brand differentiation opportunity that mandatory requirements will eventually close. The window to be seen as a transparent, health-honest drinks brand — rather than one that merely complied when legally required — is open now.
At Branding Innovations, we have always built transparency into the brand communication strategies we develop for our clients. A brand that communicates honestly about what is in its product — calories, ingredients, units, health context — earns the consumer trust that marketing budgets alone cannot buy.
The Honest Assessment: Will It Help?
Voluntary labelling on alcohol has improved significantly over the past decade. The Portman Group’s review demonstrates measurable progress. Pregnancy warnings are near-universal. Unit content is on nearly every bottle. CMO guidance is increasingly present.
But voluntary compliance has not closed the information gap. Nearly four in ten products still carry no drink-driving warning. Over a third still carry no calorie information. Ingredients remain undeclared across the entire category.
Will mandatory labelling help? The honest answer is: yes, on the margin, for some consumers — particularly those who are already health-conscious and actively seeking information. The Canadian evidence of a 6.3% consumption reduction from prominent, specific labelling is meaningful. So is the evidence that awareness of alcohol’s cancer risk increases measurably when the information is prominently presented.
Will mandatory labelling solve the UK’s relationship with alcohol? No. Labels do not change deeply habitual behaviour at scale. Social norms, price policy, and the cultural role of alcohol in UK life are all more powerful determinants of drinking patterns than what appears on the bottle.
But the argument that voluntary labelling is sufficient — when the comparison is with every other food and drink product in the same market — is no longer convincing. Mandatory requirements are coming. The only remaining questions are about format, timeline, and specific content.
For drinks brands, the most commercially intelligent response is not to lobby against mandatory requirements. It is to lead on transparency now — and to build brands that consumers trust precisely because they communicate honestly.
FAQs: Voluntary Labelling on Alcohol
Q1: What does the current voluntary labelling on alcohol system require?
The Portman Group’s voluntary best-practice guidance recommends pregnancy warnings, unit content, CMO guidelines (no more than 14 units per week), Drinkaware messaging, calorie information, drink-driving warnings, and age restriction messages. Compliance with minimum requirements is near-universal — but calorie information and drink-driving warnings remain absent from a significant proportion of products.
Q2: When will mandatory alcohol labelling come into force in the UK?
The UK Government announced in July 2025 that it would introduce mandatory requirements for nutritional information and health warnings, as part of the “Fit for the Future” 10 Year Health Plan. A consultation is underway to determine the exact wording, format, and timelines. Implementation dates have not yet been confirmed.
Q3: Does alcohol labelling actually change how much people drink?
Evidence is mixed but increasingly positive for specific types of messaging. Canadian research found that prominent labels with drinking guidelines, cancer warnings, and unit information produced a 6.3% reduction in consumption. Generic health warnings have weaker effects than specific, prominent messages tied to particular risks such as cancer.
Q4: Why is alcohol labelling treated differently from food labelling in the UK?
Historically, alcohol has been regulated separately from food, with industry self-regulation through the Portman Group rather than mandatory FSA requirements. This regulatory distinction — which means a crisp packet must declare calories but a bottle of wine does not — is increasingly difficult to justify and is the primary driver of the government’s move toward mandatory requirements.
Q5: What should alcohol brands do now to prepare for mandatory labelling?
Begin the artwork update process proactively — building comprehensive labelling into the next natural packaging revision cycle rather than waiting for a statutory deadline. Brands that lead on transparency now build consumer trust. Those who wait to be legally required to comply are seen as doing the minimum.
Q6: How does voluntary labelling affect brand trust with health-conscious consumers?
Significantly. The consumers most likely to read and act on health information are also the consumers most likely to notice its absence. Brands that voluntarily carry comprehensive, transparent health information — calories, ingredients, units, health context — in the current voluntary environment are building the consumer trust that mandatory requirements will eventually standardise.
Final Thought
Voluntary labelling on alcohol has served as a meaningful starting point and the Portman Group’s data demonstrates genuine progress. But the comparison with mandatory food labelling requirements makes the current position increasingly difficult to defend.
Mandatory requirements are coming. The government’s July 2025 announcement has made that clear. The consultation that follows will determine the specific requirements, but the direction is set.
For drinks brands, the question is not whether to comply. It is whether to lead by building transparent, honest labelling into the brand’s commercial identity now, before the regulatory requirement makes it the minimum standard rather than the differentiator.
At Branding Innovations, we help drinks brands build the kind of honest, transparent brand communication that earns consumer trust, whether that means navigating product development for alcohol-free alternatives or developing brand identities that lead with transparency. If you want to discuss what the mandatory labelling transition means for your brand, book a free consultation with us today.
Read our Book for Guidance
Richard Horwell is the Managing Director of Branding Innovations, a London-based food and drink branding and development agency. He has over 30 years of FMCG experience across the UK, USA, Australia, and the Middle East, and has been behind the development of more than 200 food and drink brands worldwide. For specialist guidance on product development and brand development, contact the Branding Innovations team today.
